Few cities move to the rhythm of military life like Colorado Springs. Between Fort Carson, Peterson Space Force Base, Schriever Space Force Base, and the U.S. Air Force Academy, every PCS season sends a wave of service members out of town with one big question hanging over them: what happens to the house? Selling feels clean and final. Renting keeps an appreciating asset working for you while you serve somewhere else. Neither answer is automatically right. The best choice depends on your equity, your loan, your tax picture, and whether the Pikes Peak region might be home again someday. Here is how we walk military owners through the decision.
Key Takeaways
- Compare your current mortgage payment and total ownership costs against realistic Colorado Springs rents before your report date.
- A low fixed mortgage rate can be one of the strongest reasons to keep a home rather than sell it.
- Military owners on qualified official extended duty may be able to suspend the IRS five-year test period, preserving the capital gains exclusion longer.
- Keeping a VA-financed home is allowed after a PCS, but it ties up entitlement you may want for your next purchase.
- Strong screening, local maintenance, and transparent reporting are what make long-distance ownership work.
Start With the Numbers, Not the Moving Truck
PCS orders compress a major financial decision into a few hectic weeks, so it helps to anchor yourself in real figures early. Begin with three numbers: what the home would likely sell for, what you still owe, and what it would rent for in today's Colorado Springs market. From there, you can run your figures through our rent vs. sell calculator to see how cash flow, appreciation, and selling costs stack up over the years you might hold the property.
Why a Low Mortgage Rate Changes the Math
Many military families bought or refinanced when rates were far lower than they are today. That payment is difficult to replace. If market rent covers your mortgage, taxes, insurance, and a reasonable reserve, keeping the home lets a tenant pay down a cheap loan while the property continues to build equity. Selling means giving up that rate permanently.
Account for the Real Costs of Renting
Rent minus mortgage is not your profit. A realistic projection includes management fees, leasing fees, occasional vacancy between tenants, routine maintenance, and a fund for bigger items like a roof, water heater, or furnace. Colorado Springs homes also face hail, freeze-thaw cycles, and dry winters that are hard on exteriors.
Understand the Tax Rules Before You Decide
Timing matters for taxes, and this is where many PCS owners leave money on the table. Under the home sale exclusion, most owners can exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for married couples filing jointly) if they owned and lived in the home for at least two of the five years before the sale. Rent the house out long enough, and that window can close.
Service members get extra breathing room. According to IRS Publication 523, members of the uniformed services on qualified official extended duty can choose to suspend the five-year test period for up to 10 years. Qualified duty generally means serving at a station at least 50 miles from the home, or living in government quarters under orders. In practice, that can allow you to rent the home for a long stretch and still qualify for the exclusion when you sell.
Two cautions apply. First, depreciation you claim (or could have claimed) while the home is a rental is generally taxed when you sell, even if the rest of the gain is excluded. Second, the rules turn on your specific facts. Before you commit to either path, talk with a tax professional who works with military clients or your installation's legal assistance office.
What VA Loan Holders Should Know
If you bought with a VA loan, you can generally keep the home and rent it out after a PCS. The VA expects military families to move, and PCS orders are a recognized reason for leaving a VA-financed home. The tradeoff is entitlement. As long as that loan stays open, the entitlement tied to it is not fully available for your next purchase. Your lender can pull an updated Certificate of Eligibility and show you exactly where you stand.
Managing a Colorado Springs Rental From Another Duty Station
The biggest worry we hear from PCS owners is not the numbers. It is the idea of managing a tenant, a broken furnace, or a late payment from Germany, Hawaii, or Virginia. That is solvable with the right systems in place.
Screening Carries More Weight When You Are Far Away
The best way to avoid problems from a distance is to place the right resident from the start. Our tenant screening process reviews income, debt-to-income ratio, credit, eviction and criminal history, and landlord references rather than leaning on a single credit score. Because so many renters here are military families, it also helps to plan for turnover. Under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, a tenant who receives qualifying PCS or deployment orders can end a residential lease early with proper notice.
Local Maintenance Protects the Asset
A frozen pipe in January or a hail-damaged roof in June needs a fast, local response. Our licensed and insured in-house maintenance team handles repair requests around the clock and documents the property with move-in inspections, so small issues get addressed before they become expensive claims. Meanwhile, a 24/7 owner portal keeps statements, invoices, and inspection reports available on your schedule, in any time zone.
When Selling Makes More Sense
Renting is not the right fit for everyone. Selling often wins if the rent would not cover your costs, you have no plans to return to Colorado, you need the equity for a home at your next station, or the property needs major work before it could rent well. If selling is the better move, our real estate team can help with pricing and listing so the transition stays on schedule.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Generally, yes. Once you have met the VA's occupancy requirement, or receive PCS orders that move you away, you can keep the loan in place and rent the home. Keep in mind that the entitlement tied to that loan may limit your next VA purchase.
- Not necessarily. Service members on qualified official extended duty can suspend the five-year test period for up to 10 years. Depreciation recapture still applies, so confirm the details with a tax professional.
- Federal law allows military tenants with qualifying orders to end a lease early with written notice. We plan for that turnover so your home gets back on the market quickly.
Keep Your Options Open While You Serve
A PCS move does not have to force a rushed sale or an anxious first year as a long-distance landlord. With clear numbers, a solid grasp of the tax and VA rules, and a local team handling the day-to-day, many military owners find that holding their Colorado Springs home is one of the smartest moves they make.
Not sure whether to rent or sell before you PCS?
If you are weighing your options before your report date, we would be glad to prepare a free rental analysis and walk you through our Colorado Springs property management services.
Colorado Springs property management services
